Buyer's checklist
How to choose a software development company
Hiring someone to build your software is a significant decision. This checklist covers what to ask, what to watch out for, and how to compare proposals fairly.
Start with fit, not technology
The best software partners spend the first conversations on your business: who does the work, where it gets stuck, what "better" would look like and how you'll measure it. Technology choices come later and should follow from the problem.
If a company leads with frameworks, buzzwords or a pre-packaged platform before understanding your process, that's a sign the solution may be decided before the problem is.
Questions to ask every candidate
Ask the same questions of everyone you talk to, and listen for specific, plain-English answers.
- How do you learn how our business works before proposing a solution?
- What does your discovery and design process look like, and what will we see before development starts?
- How often will we see working software during the build?
- Who exactly will design and build it, and who do we talk to day to day?
- How do you handle testing, security and data migration?
- What happens after launch — support, maintenance, and changes?
- How are ownership of the code, designs and data handled, and what does handover look like if we part ways?
- Can you show examples of interfaces or applications you've designed? (Ask whether they are client work, concepts or demos.)
Red flags to watch for
None of these automatically rules a company out, but each deserves a direct question.
- A firm price before anyone has understood your requirements.
- No discovery or design phase — straight from a phone call to coding.
- Reluctance to show work in progress until the end of the project.
- Vague answers about who is doing the work, or frequent changes in who you'll talk to.
- Unclear terms on code ownership, hosting accounts, or what happens if the relationship ends.
- No plan for maintenance, security updates or changes after launch.
- Claims that can't be checked: unnamed "Fortune 500 clients," awards without sources, or impressive statistics with no context.
How to compare proposals fairly
Proposals are hard to compare when each one assumes a different scope. Write a short description of what you need — the problem, the people, the systems involved and what a successful first version does — and give the same document to every candidate.
Then compare line by line. Is testing included? Data migration? Integrations? Training? Documentation? Support after launch? A lower price that excludes these may cost more in the end. Also compare how each company proposes to reduce risk, such as a phased first release.
Local, remote, or both?
Software can be built from anywhere, but location still matters for some projects. A local partner makes it easy to sit with your team, watch how work actually happens and run design sessions in a room together — which is often where the most important requirements surface. A remote partner widens your choice of skills and availability.
For many businesses the best answer is a mix: in-person discovery and key workshops, with the build and day-to-day collaboration done remotely. For example, Level Up Automate is based in Rhode Island and serves businesses across the Northeast and nationwide. We collaborate remotely, with in-person discovery and design sessions available in Rhode Island and Greater Boston.
Size of firm: does it matter?
Large agencies offer depth and capacity; small studios and independent developers often offer more direct access to the person building your software and lower overhead. What matters most is a good fit for your project's size, clear communication, a sensible process and honest answers. Ask who will actually do the work, and make sure their availability matches your timeline.
A short checklist
Before signing, you should be able to say yes to most of these.
- They understand our process and can explain it back to us.
- We've agreed a written scope and a written estimate.
- We know who is building it and how we'll communicate.
- We'll see working software regularly during the project.
- Testing, data migration and launch support are included or clearly priced.
- Ownership, hosting and handover terms are written down.
- There's a plan for support and improvements after launch.
What a good first engagement looks like
Many businesses reduce risk by starting with a small, paid first step rather than committing to a full build immediately. That might be a discovery and design phase that produces workflow maps, clickable screens and a firm scope, or a focused first release that solves one painful problem.
A small first engagement tells you a great deal: how the partner communicates, whether they understood your business, how they handle feedback and whether their estimates hold up. If it goes well, the larger project starts on solid ground. If it doesn't, you've learned that cheaply.
Common questions
Frequently asked questions
What should I look for in a software development company?
Look for a partner who asks about your business before technology, has a clear discovery and design process, shows working software regularly, explains testing and security, and puts scope, cost, ownership and support terms in writing.
What questions should I ask a software developer before hiring?
Ask how they learn your process, what you'll see before development starts, how often you'll see working software, who will do the work, how testing and data migration are handled, what support looks like after launch, and how code ownership and handover work.
What are red flags when hiring a software company?
Common red flags are a firm price before requirements are understood, no discovery phase, reluctance to show work in progress, vague answers about who does the work, unclear ownership terms and no plan for maintenance.
Is it better to hire a local or remote software developer?
Both can work. Local developers make in-person discovery and workshops easy, which helps uncover requirements. Remote developers widen your options. Many projects combine in-person discovery with remote development.
How do I compare software development quotes?
Give every candidate the same written description of what you need, then compare what each quote includes: design, testing, integrations, data migration, training, documentation and post-launch support. Compare total value, not just price.
Should I choose a big agency or a small studio?
Choose based on fit. Large agencies offer capacity; small studios often provide direct access to the person building your software. Prioritize clear communication, a sensible process and honest answers over size.
Next step
Want help putting this into practice?
Tell us what you're working on. You'll get a straight answer on what to build, connect or automate first — and what it would take.